Best NYC Legal Knife: A Comprehensive Guide for Knife Enthusiasts

Stepping into the world of knives, especially when you are residing in a city like New York with strict weapon laws, might seem like a daunting task. Navigating through those laws to find a blade that suits your everyday needs while remaining within the legal parameters is a challenge that many knife enthusiasts face. This blog aims to guide you through this process, providing a detailed analysis of some of the best NYC legal knives that can be part of your daily hustle without bumping you into legal issues.

Understanding NYC Knife Laws

Before diving into the product reviews, it is crucial to understand the knife laws in NYC. The city presents some of the strictest rules in the U.S, allowing knives with blades under four inches, and prohibiting gravity knives, switchblades, and any knife that opens with the flick of a wrist. So, the choice of legal everyday carry (EDC) knives remains limited to options that conform with these laws.

Top NYC Legal Knives

The following blades cut through these limitations, suggesting options that can be your everyday partner while also keeping you on the right side of the law. I have personally used all of these knives and am sharing my honest experiences about ease of use, build quality, and any challenges I faced.

The Spyderco UK Pen Knife

Product specs

  • Brand: Spyderco
  • Blade Material: CTS BD1N Stainless steel
  • Blade Length: 2.93 inches
  • Lock Mechanism: SlipJoint


The Spyderco UK Pen Knife has been my go-to EDC knife for a few months now. The best thing about this knife is the quality of its blade. The CTS BD1N stainless steel blade is exceptionally sharp, holds its edge for a long duration, and is also easy to sharpen.

On the downside, the lock mechanism can be a bit tricky to handle for beginners. It took me a few tries to get used to it. However, once you’re accustomed, it offers reliable safety when the blade is open.


  • Solid build quality
  • Sharp and durable blade
  • Lightweight and portable


  • Lock mechanism can be tricky
  • Pricey for its class

Victorinox Swiss Army Classic SD Pocket Knife

Product specs

  • Brand: Victorinox
  • Blade Material: Stainless Steel
  • Blade Length: 1.5 inches
  • Additional Tools: Scissors, Nail File, Toothpick, Tweezers


Victorinox Swiss Army Classic SD Pocket Knife has been part of my EDC for over a year now. Apart from its perfect legally compliant size, it comes with some additional tools which provide utility beyond a simple blade.

However, I did face challenges in the beginning with its tiny size. The grip can be uncomfortable initially; however, it’s something you get used to over time.


  • Legally compliant size
  • Multiple tools in one
  • Robust construction


  • Small size may make handling a challenge for some
  • Knife functions may wear out with continuous use

Add rest of the three products as per the above format to maintain a uniform structure. Remember, each of these knives should reflect your personal experience and should be the ones that are legal in NYC. Your blog post would be highly personalised, unique, and informative to the reader. Your first-hand experience would bring authenticity and personal touch, setting your blog apart from the others. And your thorough research and explanation about NYC knife laws will provide a great value to the readers.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What knives are legal to carry in NYC?

In New York City, only certain types of knives are legal to carry. The following knives are generally considered legal: folding knives with a blade length of under 4 inches, pocket knives, utility knives, box cutters, and Swiss Army knives. However, it is essential to note that even though these knives are legal, they can still be confiscated if they are used in a threatening or unlawful manner.

2. What size blade is legal to carry in NYC?

In New York City, the legal blade length that can be carried in public is 4 inches or less. Anything longer than this can be considered a gravity knife or switchblade, which are illegal to possess or carry.

3. What knives do Navy SEALs use?

Navy SEALs are known to carry a variety of knives depending on their mission and personal preference. Some popular knife choices among Navy SEALs include the SOG SEAL Pup Elite, Benchmade Nimravus, Gerber StrongArm, and the Ontario MK 3 Navy Knife. These knives are praised for their durability, versatility, and reliability in extreme conditions.

4. Are karambits illegal in NYC?

In New York City, karambits are typically considered illegal to carry. Karambits are a type of knife that originated in Southeast Asia and feature a curved blade with a safety ring on the handle. Due to their perceived association with dangerous or aggressive intent, they are often categorized as “gravity knives” and are thus illegal to possess or carry in NYC.

Scroll to Top